Illinois Healthcare News| August 1, 2018
Illinois Lawmakers Calling for Hearing and Overhaul of Health Care Association
The fallout from racially charged remarks that led to the resignation of Illinois Primary Health Care Association’s CEO Bruce Johnson intensified this week, with Illinois lawmakers suggesting widespread bias in the IPHCA group and calling for an investigation into its practices.
Bruce Johnson resigned as president and CEO of IPHCA on June 16 after he admitted to making offensive comments during a meeting with Raul Garza, CEO of Aunt Martha’s, an IPHCA member and private nonprofit agency that provides medical and child welfare services to low-income patients across Illinois.
Days later, six executive members who failed to sanction Johnson, stepped down as well.
Aunt Martha’s has called for an investigation into the group, and Illinois Latino lawmakers are stepping up to support its mission.
Sen. Martin Sandoval, co-chairman of the Illinois Legislative Latino Caucus called for legislative hearings to “investigate the trail of racism surrounding the resignation of Illinois Primary Health Care Association (IPHCA) President and CEO Bruce Johnson,” in a press release this week.
Sandoval believes that Johnson’s racist comments hint at a bigger issue. “This was a sustained campaign of intimidation by not just Bruce Johnson but several members of the [IPHCA] executive board.”
Sandoval plans to file a resolution to conduct an audit of the IPHCA’s adherence to its contracts with the state of Illinois. “This type of discourse will no longer be tolerated,” he added.
More state and local elected officials called for the resignation of leadership and reform of the IPHCA.
“I think the General Assembly should hold their feet to the fire,” said 12th Ward Alderman George Cardenas.
Cook County Commissioner Jesus “Chuy” Garcia also commented: “The one thing I haven’t heard, first and foremost, is an apology.”
Soon after Johnson’s resignation, IPHCA announced the formation of a Diversity and Inclusion Committee. Gordon Eggers, chair of the association’s board, said in a memo to members that they “are committed to taking additional steps to ensure this never happens again.”
For some, this decision was seen as a “band-Aid on a festering wound.”
In a recent interview, Garza said he welcomed Johnson’s resignation, but will continue to seek a full investigation and “root out the blatant racism that exists within the IPHCA’s leadership.” Garza pointed out that while more than one-third of the patients IPHCA members serve are Latino, no Latinos serve in a leadership capacity within the association.
Johnson’s behavior came to light on July 14, when Garza sent a memo to IPHCA members. According to Garza, during a June 20 meeting, Johnson made “insufficiently veiled threats toward Aunt Martha’s.”
Garza, a U.S.-born citizen of Mexican descent and a 12-year veteran of the United States Air Force, also said that Johnson asked “if Trump lets me back into the country when I travel to Mexico.”
Aunt Martha’s sent a confidential letter to IPHCA’s Executive Committee on June 29, asking for a “legally sound investigation.”
Meanwhile, is believed that Johnson, who worked for the IPHCA for nearly 30 years, was tipped off by an executive committee member. Johnson attempted an apology via voicemail, saying he “really didn’t mean to be racist.”
Three weeks passed without any action from IPHCA’s part. IPHCA later said that it couldn’t move forward because Garza wouldn’t provide witness affidavits.
In his memo, Garza, argued that “The Executive Committee has acted with defiance toward the victim and sympathy for the accused, graciously allowing Mr. Johnson to retire a full 13 months from now, the same date on which many of you have known he’d planned to step down even before this incident came to light.”
The public pressure soon led to Johnson’s resignation.
Aunt Martha’s has filed official complaints with state and federal agencies that oversee the Illinois Primary Health Care Association such as the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, the Inspector General to the Illinois Department of Public Health and the Illinois Department of Human Services.
By joining their efforts, lawmakers, health care leaders and Aunt Martha hope to nudge IPHCA’s Assembly of Delegates into ensuring that new leadership reflects the populations served by its membership.
For health care businesses in Illinois, this incident holds two essential lessons.
On one hand, health executives are reminded that partnering with other organizations comes with challenges.
Finding common ground, however, pays dividends in the form of improved service, increased customers satisfaction, higher profit and, most importantly, innovation.
On the other hand, it’s reassuring to see that Illinois lawmakers were quick to react against the abuse of power of such an established organization as IPHCA.
Strengthening relationships with local representatives is the first step towards reform in health care.